Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhitha-Assignment 1-Part B - Murder and Culpable Homicide

Murder and Culpable Homicide Not Amounting to Murder Under BNS, 2023

 Introduction

The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, replaces the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and provides a modern legal framework for criminal law in India. Among the most serious offenses under this law are Murder and Culpable Homicide Not Amounting to Murder. These offenses are covered under Section 101 and Section 105 of BNS, respectively.

While both involve the unlawful killing of a person, the key difference lies in the intent and circumstances surrounding the act. Murder is the most serious offense as it is committed with a direct intention to kill. Culpable homicide, on the other hand, is a broader category that includes killings where the death was caused without the specific intent to murder but under circumstances where death was a likely consequence.

To understand these two offenses clearly, it is important to examine their definitions, elements, and distinctions. This assignment will explain Murder (Section 101) and Culpable Homicide Not Amounting to Murder (Section 105) in detail and highlight their differences with relevant legal perspectives.

---

Definition and Elements of Murder (Section 101, BNS, 2023)

Definition:
Under Section 101 of BNS, 2023, Murder is defined as a culpable homicide that fulfills certain aggravating conditions. A person commits murder if:

1. The act is done with the intention of causing death.
2. The act is done with the intention of causing bodily injury, which is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death.
3. The act is done with the knowledge that it is so imminently dangerous that it must, in all probability, cause death or such bodily injury leading to death.

Key Elements of Murder:

1. Intention: There must be a clear intention to cause death or serious bodily injury.
2. Knowledge: The accused must know that their act will likely result in death.
3. Direct Cause: The act must be directly responsible for the victim’s death.
4. No Justification: The act should not fall under any legal exceptions (like self-defense).

Example:
If A stabs B in the chest with a knife, knowing that the injury is sufficient to cause death, it is murder because there was a clear intent to kill.

---

Definition and Elements of Culpable Homicide Not Amounting to Murder (Section 105, BNS, 2023)

Definition:
Section 105 of BNS, 2023, defines Culpable Homicide Not Amounting to Murder as the act of causing death without the clear intention to kill but with knowledge that the act is likely to cause death.

Key Elements of Culpable Homicide:

1. Act causes death: There must be a direct connection between the act and the death.
2. Knowledge but no intention: The accused must have known that the act could cause death, but there was no definite intent to kill.
3. Lower degree of mens rea (guilty mind): The accused may have acted recklessly or negligently.

Example:
If A and B get into a fight, and A pushes B off a building without intending to kill, but knowing that the push is likely to cause death, it is culpable homicide, not murder.

Key Distinction:

• Murder requires direct intention, whereas culpable homicide may involve reckless or negligent actions leading to death.

---

 Differences Between Murder and Culpable Homicide

Factor	Murder (Section 101)	Culpable Homicide (Section 105)
Intent	Clear intention to kill.	No clear intent, but knowledge that death may occur.
Severity	More serious offense.	Lesser degree of severity.
Mens Rea (Guilty Mind)	Strong intent and knowledge of fatal consequences.	Act done in a reckless/negligent manner.
Punishment	Death penalty or life imprisonment.	Imprisonment up to 10 years or life, depending on circumstances.
Examples	Stabbing someone in the heart to kill them.	Pushing someone in anger, leading to their death.

Case Example:

• Murder: A person shoots someone in the head with the intention to kill.
• Culpable Homicide: A person punches someone, and they fall, hit their head, and die unexpectedly.

---

Legal Consequences and Punishment

Punishment for Murder (Section 101, BNS, 2023)

Under BNS, 2023, the punishment for murder includes:

1. Death penalty – In rarest of rare cases.
2. Life imprisonment – In most cases.
3. Fine – As decided by the court.

Punishment for Culpable Homicide (Section 105, BNS, 2023)

Punishment varies based on the severity of the act:

1. If the act is done with knowledge but not intention: Imprisonment for up to 10 years or life.
2. If the act is done negligently: Lesser punishment, ranging from fine to imprisonment for a few years.

Case Law Examples:

1. Murder: If a person poisons another with the clear intention to kill, it results in death penalty or life imprisonment.
2. Culpable Homicide: If a person slaps someone and they fall down the stairs, resulting in death, the punishment is less severe than murder.

---

Conclusion

The distinction between murder and culpable homicide is a crucial aspect of criminal law. Murder is the more severe offense due to the presence of direct intent, while culpable homicide may occur without a direct intention to kill.

The punishments differ based on the severity and intent of the act, ensuring that justice is served fairly. Courts carefully analyze the intent, circumstances, and consequences before deciding whether a case falls under murder or culpable homicide.

In conclusion, understanding these distinctions is essential for legal professionals, law students, and citizens, as it helps in identifying the degree of criminal liability in homicide cases. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, provides a structured legal framework to address these offenses in a modern and just manner.

---