The transfer of property by Exchange is a legally recognized form of transfer, governed by Chapter VI (Sections 118 to 121) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TPA). It is fundamentally a mutual transfer of ownership where two different properties substitute for consideration.
1. Definition and Essentials (Section 118)
A. Statutory Definition
Section 118 of the TPA defines an Exchange as:
"When two persons mutually transfer the ownership of one thing for the ownership of another, neither thing or both things being money only, the transaction is called an 'exchange'."
B. Core Essentials
Two Persons: There must be at least two competent parties (transferors/transferees).
Mutual Transfer of Ownership: The essence is reciprocity; both parties must transfer the absolute ownership of their respective properties to each other. Both parties simultaneously act as transferor and transferee.
Transfer of 'Thing': The things exchanged may be movable property, immovable property, or a combination of both.
Exclusion of Pure Money: The consideration cannot be money only. If the consideration for the transfer of property is only money, the transaction is a Sale (Section 54), not an exchange. If the exchange involves Property A for Property B plus a sum of money (to balance the value difference), it remains an exchange.
C. Mode of Transfer
The completion of a transfer by exchange must be made in the same manner as is provided for the transfer of such property by Sale (Section 118).
Immovable Property: If the exchange involves immovable property valued at ₹100 or more, the transfer must be effected by a registered instrument (registered deed).
2. Exchange vs. Sale
Though similar to a sale, exchange is legally distinct in terms of consideration:
3. Rights and Liabilities of Parties (Section 120)
The TPA ensures that the mutual transfers in an exchange impose the same legal duties on both parties as if they were sellers and buyers.
Section 120 states:
"Save as otherwise provided in this Chapter, each party has the rights and is subject to the liabilities of a seller as to that which he gives, and has the rights and is subject to the liabilities of a buyer as to that which he tak
es."
A. Dual Liabilities (Seller's Duties)
Each party, in respect of the property they are giving away, is subject to the liabilities of a seller (Section 55, TPA), including the duty to:
Disclose Material Defects: Disclose any material defect in the property (e.g., a defect in title) which the other party could not discover.
Warrant Title: Guarantee that they have the legal right to transfer the interest in the property.
B. Warranty of Genuineness of Money (Section 121)
If the exchange involves money (as partial consideration), Section 121 mandates that each party warrants the genuineness of the money given by them. If the money turns out to be counterfeit, the transaction may be voided, or compensation may be claimed.
4. Remedy for Defective Title (Section 119)
A critical safeguard in an exchange is the remedy provided if one party is deprived of the property received due to a defect in the other party's title.
Section 119 grants the deprived party the right to:
Compensation: Recover compensation for the loss sustained.
Return of Property: Request the return of the property originally transferred by them, provided that property is still in the possession of the other party or persons claiming under them (other than a bona fide purchaser for value without notice).
This implied covenant for title ensures that a party does not lose both the property they gave up and the property they received in the exchange.
The video below offers an explanation of the exchange provisions within the Transfer of Property Act.
Comments
Post a Comment