Tax was a direct tax levied on the net wealth of certain categories of persons in India. It was governed by the Wealth Tax Act, 1957, which was enacted with the primary objective of reducing economic inequality by taxing the accumulated wealth of rich individuals, Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs), and companies. The Wealth Tax Act operated alongside the Income Tax Act, 1961 to form a comprehensive system of direct taxation in India.
It is important to note at the outset that the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 was abolished with effect from 1st April, 2016 by the Finance Act, 2015. Despite its abolition, the concept of net wealth and the general principles relating to the charge of wealth tax remain important academic topics and continue to be examined in law courses.
The Wealth Tax Act was based on the principle enunciated in the Directive Principles of State Policy under Article 39(c) of the Constitution of India, which directs the State to ensure that the operation of the economic system does not result in the concentration of wealth and means of production to the common detriment.
Definition of Net Wealth — Section 2(m)
Under Section 2(m) of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957, "net wealth" is defined as:
"The amount by which the aggregate value computed in accordance with the provisions of this Act of all the assets, wherever located, belonging to the assessee on the valuation date, including assets required to be included in his net wealth as on that date under this Act, is in excess of the aggregate value of all the debts owed by the assessee on the valuation date other than (i) debts which are secured on, or which have been incurred in relation to, assets not includible in computing net wealth; and (ii) debts which have been incurred in relation to assets in respect of which wealth tax is not chargeable under this Act."
In simple terms:
Net Wealth = Total Value of Taxable Assets − Debts Related to Those Assets
Components of Net Wealth
A. Assets Included in Net Wealth — Section 2(ea)
The Wealth Tax Act does not tax all assets but only specified assets listed in Section 2(ea). These are:
1. Buildings and Land Any building or land appurtenant thereto including a farmhouse situated within 25 kilometres of the local limits of any municipality. However, the following buildings are excluded:
- Property used for business or profession by the assessee
- Property held as stock-in-trade
- Property let out for 300 days or more in the previous year
- Any one house (or part of a house) used for residential purposes
2. Motor Cars Motor cars owned by the assessee other than:
- Motor cars used by the assessee in his business of running them on hire
- Motor cars held as stock-in-trade
3. Jewelry, Bullion, Furniture Jewelry, bullion, furniture, utensils, or any other article made wholly or partly of:
- Gold
- Silver
- Platinum
- Any other precious metal
- Precious or semi-precious stones
Whether set in any furniture, utensil, or other article or not, other than those held as stock-in-trade.
4. Yachts, Boats, and Aircraft Yachts, boats, and aircraft other than those used by the assessee for commercial purposes.
5. Urban Land Land situated in urban areas (within municipal limits or within 8 kilometres of municipal limits and notified by the Central Government) other than:
- Land on which construction of a building is not permissible under law
- Land occupied by a building which is used for business or profession
- Unused land held for industrial purposes for a period of 2 years from the date of acquisition
- Land held as stock-in-trade for a period of 10 years from the date of acquisition
6. Cash in Hand Cash in hand in excess of ₹50,000 for individuals and HUFs. For companies, any amount of cash not recorded in the books of account.
B. Debts Deductible from Net Wealth
Only debts that are directly related to the taxable assets can be deducted from the value of those assets to arrive at net wealth. The following debts are not deductible:
- Debts secured on or incurred in relation to assets not includible in net wealth
- Debts incurred in relation to assets exempt from wealth tax
Examples of deductible debts:
- Mortgage loan taken to purchase a building included in net wealth
- Loan taken to buy a motor car included in net wealth
General Principles Relating to Charge of Wealth Tax
Principle 1 — Charge of Wealth Tax — Section 3
Section 3 of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 is the charging section — the most fundamental provision of the Act. It states:
"Subject to the other provisions of this Act, there shall be charged for every assessment year commencing on and from the 1st day of April, 1957, a tax (hereinafter referred to as wealth tax) in respect of the net wealth on the corresponding valuation date of every individual, Hindu undivided family and company at the rate or rates specified in Schedule I."
This provision establishes five essential elements for the charge of wealth tax:
1. There must be a net wealth — The tax is charged on net wealth as defined under Section 2(m).
2. It must belong to a specified person — Only individuals, HUFs, and companies are liable to wealth tax. Firms, Association of Persons (AOPs), and other entities are not liable.
3. It must exist on the valuation date — The net wealth must be assessed as on the valuation date (31st March immediately preceding the assessment year).
4. It must exceed the basic exemption limit — Wealth tax is chargeable only on net wealth exceeding ₹30 lakhs.
5. It must be charged at the prescribed rate — Wealth tax is charged at 1% of the net wealth exceeding ₹30 lakhs.
Principle 2 — Persons Liable to Wealth Tax
Under Section 3, the following persons are liable to wealth tax:
1. Individual Every individual (whether resident or non-resident) is liable to wealth tax if his net wealth exceeds the basic exemption limit. The residential status determines whether foreign assets are included in net wealth.
2. Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) Every HUF is liable to wealth tax on its net wealth. The HUF is taxed as a separate entity distinct from its individual members.
3. Company Every company (whether Indian or foreign) is liable to wealth tax. However, after several amendments, most companies were exempt from wealth tax, and only companies that were not engaged in business and held chargeable assets were liable.
The following are NOT liable to wealth tax:
- Firms and AOPs — These entities are not chargeable to wealth tax. However, a partner's share in firm property may be included in his individual net wealth in certain circumstances.
- Charitable and religious trusts — Exempt under Section 5
- Political parties
- Mutual funds
Principle 3 — Valuation Date — Section 2(q)
Under Section 2(q), the valuation date is the 31st day of March immediately preceding the assessment year. This means:
- For Assessment Year 2015-16, the valuation date is 31st March, 2015
- The net wealth is assessed as on this specific date
- Assets acquired after the valuation date are not included
- Assets disposed of before the valuation date are not included
Principle 4 — Rate of Wealth Tax
Wealth tax was levied at a flat rate of 1% on net wealth exceeding ₹30 lakhs. This rate was uniform for all categories of assessees (individuals, HUFs, and companies) and did not have a progressive structure.
Example of Calculation: If an individual's net wealth on the valuation date is ₹80 lakhs:
- Basic exemption = ₹30 lakhs
- Taxable net wealth = ₹80 lakhs − ₹30 lakhs = ₹50 lakhs
- Wealth tax = 1% of ₹50 lakhs = ₹50,000
Principle 5 — Residential Status and Scope of Net Wealth
The residential status of the assessee determines which assets are included in net wealth:
Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR): Net wealth includes ALL assets — both in India and outside India.
Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident (RNOR) and Non-Resident: Net wealth includes only assets located in India.
Foreign companies: Net wealth includes only assets located in India.
Principle 6 — Assets Exempt from Wealth Tax — Section 5
The following assets are specifically exempt from wealth tax under Section 5:
1. Property held under trust for public charitable or religious purposes Any property held by a trust or institution for charitable or religious purposes is exempt from wealth tax.
2. Interest in coparcenary property The interest of a member of an HUF in the coparcenary property of the HUF is exempt in the hands of the individual member (to avoid double taxation since the HUF itself is taxed).
3. One residential house One house or part of a house (or a plot of land not exceeding 500 square metres) used for residential purposes is exempt. This exemption is available only to individuals and HUFs.
4. Assets of a former ruler Jewellery in possession of a former ruler that is recognized as his heirloom (ancestral property) is exempt.
5. Assets of a diplomatic representative Assets belonging to a diplomatic representative or consular officer of a foreign country are exempt subject to reciprocity.
6. Indian repatriates Assets brought to India by a returning NRI are exempt for a period of 7 assessment years from the year of return.
Principle 7 — Deemed Assets — Section 4
Under Section 4, certain assets are deemed to be assets of the assessee even though they may legally belong to another person. This prevents tax avoidance through transfer of assets. The following are deemed assets:
1. Assets transferred to spouse Assets transferred by an individual to his or her spouse otherwise than for adequate consideration or in connection with an agreement to live apart are deemed to be the assets of the transferor.
2. Assets transferred to minor child Assets transferred to a minor child (other than a married daughter) otherwise than for adequate consideration are deemed to be the assets of the transferor parent.
3. Assets held by a person on behalf of the assessee Assets held by any person as an agent, nominee, or trustee on behalf of the assessee are deemed to be the assets of the assessee.
4. Assets converted from HUF property If an individual converts his self-acquired property into HUF property, such property is deemed to be the individual's asset for wealth tax purposes.
Principle 8 — Valuation of Assets — Sections 7 and 8 and Schedule III
The value of assets for wealth tax purposes is determined according to the rules in Schedule III of the Wealth Tax Act. The general principle is that assets are valued at their market value on the valuation date — i.e., the price that the asset would fetch if sold in the open market on the valuation date.
Special valuation rules exist for:
- Immovable property — valued based on the capitalized value of rent or the market value, whichever is higher
- Shares and securities — valued based on prescribed rules
- Jewelry and bullion — valued at market price on the valuation date
Principle 9 — Assessment Procedure
The assessment procedure under the Wealth Tax Act was broadly similar to that under the Income Tax Act:
1. Filing of Return — Under Section 14, every assessee liable to wealth tax must file a return of net wealth in the prescribed form.
2. Self-Assessment — The assessee calculates his own wealth tax liability and pays it before filing the return.
3. Scrutiny Assessment — The Wealth Tax Officer can scrutinize the return and make additions or deletions.
4. Best Judgment Assessment — If no return is filed, the Wealth Tax Officer can make a best judgment assessment.
Principle 10 — Appeals and Penalties
The Wealth Tax Act provided for a hierarchy of appeals similar to the Income Tax Act:
- Commissioner of Wealth Tax (Appeals)
- Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT)
- High Court (on substantial questions of law)
- Supreme Court
Penalties were prescribed for:
- Failure to file return
- Concealment of net wealth
- Failure to pay wealth tax on time
Abolition of Wealth Tax — Finance Act, 2015
The Finance Act, 2015 abolished the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 with effect from Assessment Year 2016-17 (i.e., from 1st April, 2016). The reasons for abolition were:
- Low revenue — Wealth tax collected was only about ₹1,000 crore per year, which was disproportionately low compared to the administrative cost of collection
- Easy avoidance — Wealthy individuals could easily avoid wealth tax by investing in financial assets (shares, bonds, mutual funds) which were not chargeable assets
- Administrative burden — The Act required valuation of assets which was time-consuming and led to disputes
- Replacement — The government introduced an additional surcharge of 2% on super-rich income taxpayers (income above ₹1 crore) to compensate for the loss of wealth tax revenue
Important Case Laws
1. CWT v. Arvind Narottam (1988)
The Supreme Court held that only assets specifically mentioned in Section 2(ea) are chargeable to wealth tax. Assets not mentioned in Section 2(ea) cannot be included in net wealth even if they represent accumulated wealth.
2. CWT v. Ellis Bridge Gymkhana (1998)
The Supreme Court held that a club is not an individual, HUF, or company and therefore is not liable to wealth tax. Only the three categories of persons mentioned in Section 3 are liable.
3. CWT v. Sharvan Kumar Swarup (1994)
The Supreme Court held that the valuation of assets for wealth tax purposes must be done as per Schedule III and not at cost price or book value.
4. CIT v. Gestetner Duplicators Pvt. Ltd. (1979)
The court held that the deemed asset provisions under Section 4 must be strictly construed and cannot be extended beyond their express terms.
5. CWT v. HH Maharaja Martand Singh (1978)
The court held that jewellery recognized as heirloom property of a former ruler is exempt from wealth tax under Section 5.
Conclusion
The Wealth Tax Act, 1957 was an important instrument of fiscal policy aimed at reducing the concentration of wealth in the hands of a few and promoting greater economic equality in India. The concept of net wealth — defined as the excess of taxable assets over related debts — formed the foundation of the Act. The general principles relating to the charge of wealth tax — including the identification of taxable persons, the valuation date, the rate of tax, the scope of net wealth, and the exemptions available — created a comprehensive framework for taxing accumulated wealth. While the Act has been abolished, its principles remain academically important and reflect the constitutional aspiration of reducing economic inequality through progressive taxation. The abolition of wealth tax and its replacement by a surcharge on super-rich income taxpayers reflects the pragmatic evolution of Indian tax policy towards more efficient and effective means of taxing the wealthy.
Comments
Post a Comment