A Property Mark is an important concept in Indian law that predates modern trade mark law. It is governed by Sections 479 to 485 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC). A property mark is a mark used to indicate that a particular movable property belongs to a specific person. Unlike a trade mark (which indicates the commercial origin of goods), a property mark indicates ownership of property. The provisions of the IPC relating to property marks are designed to prevent fraudulent use of such marks and to protect the ownership rights of persons in their movable property.
Meaning and Definition of Property Mark
Section 479 of the Indian Penal Code defines a property mark as:
"A mark used for denoting that movable property belongs to a particular person is called a property mark."
In simple terms, a property mark is any mark — a symbol, letter, number, or design — that is put on movable property to indicate who it belongs to.
Examples of property marks:
- A farmer's mark branded on his cattle
- A laundry mark sewn into clothing
- A stamp or brand on timber logs to identify the owner
- A mark on tools or equipment to indicate ownership
- A mark on luggage to identify the owner
Distinction Between Property Mark and Trade Mark
| Property Mark | Trade Mark |
|---|---|
| Indicates ownership of property | Indicates commercial origin of goods |
| Governed by Indian Penal Code | Governed by Trade Marks Act, 1999 |
| No registration required | Registration gives statutory protection |
| Primarily criminal law protection | Both civil and criminal protection |
| Mark is on the property of the owner | Mark is on goods sold to customers |
| Example: Brand on cattle | Example: "Tata" on cars |
Offences Relating to Property Marks Under IPC
The IPC creates several criminal offences relating to the fraudulent use of property marks:
1. Section 482 — Punishment for Using a False Property Mark Whoever uses any false property mark shall be punished with imprisonment up to 1 year, or fine, or both.
A false property mark is a mark that falsely represents that property belongs to a person to whom it does not belong.
2. Section 483 — Counterfeiting a Property Mark Whoever counterfeits any property mark used by any other person shall be punished with imprisonment up to 2 years, or fine, or both.
Counterfeiting means making a mark that is intended to pass as the genuine property mark of another person.
3. Section 484 — Possession of Instrument for Counterfeiting a Property Mark Whoever has in his possession any instrument for the purpose of counterfeiting a property mark shall be punished with imprisonment up to 3 years, and fine.
4. Section 485 — Making or Possession of Any Instrument for Counterfeiting Whoever makes or has in his possession any die, plate, or other instrument for the purpose of using or enabling another person to use such instrument for counterfeiting a property mark shall be punished with imprisonment up to 3 years, and fine.
Property Mark in the Context of Forest Laws
Property marks are particularly important in the forest industry where logs and timber are marked to indicate ownership. The Indian Forest Act, 1927 contains specific provisions relating to property marks on forest produce. Any unauthorized removal of a property mark from forest produce or fraudulent alteration of such marks is an offence under the Forest Act.
Property Mark vs. Trade Mark Under the Designs Act
The Designs Act, 2000 specifically excludes property marks (as defined in the IPC) from the definition of "design" under Section 2(d). This means a property mark cannot be registered as an industrial design.
Important Case Laws
1. State v. Ramlal (1950) The court held that a property mark under Section 479 IPC must be a mark that is actually used to denote ownership — a merely decorative mark on property does not constitute a property mark.
2. Gobind Lal v. Emperor (1923) The court held that the offence of using a false property mark under Section 482 IPC requires that the mark be used with fraudulent intent — accidental use of a similar mark is not an offence.
Significance of Property Mark in Modern Law
While the concept of property mark is less prominent in modern commercial practice (where trade marks and branding have taken center stage), it remains relevant in several contexts:
- Agricultural property — Marking of livestock and farm equipment
- Forest produce — Marking of timber and logs
- Industrial equipment — Marking of tools and machinery for identification
- Government property — Marking of government assets to prevent theft or misappropriation
Conclusion
The concept of property mark, though one of the older forms of intellectual property protection in India, continues to serve an important function in protecting ownership rights in movable property. The criminal law framework under the IPC provides effective deterrence against fraudulent use of property marks. While modern trade mark law has largely superseded property marks in commercial contexts, the property mark remains an important legal concept in areas like agriculture, forestry, and industrial property management. An understanding of property marks provides valuable historical and comparative context for the study of modern intellectual property law in India.
Comments
Post a Comment